IR35 was introduced as new legislation as part of the Finance Act 1999, as a way of plugging the £900million loophole in the tax law of the time.
Up until this legislation, contractors operated through either an umbrella or limited company. In doing so they were free to manage their income themselves, normally with the assistance of an accountant. You will know, if you have been contracting for a while that historically this included low salary levels being drawn together with expenses, with a balance usually paid as a dividend. Dividends were taken rather than salary as they do not attract National Insurance deductions and they also allowed income to be passed to other individuals (normally people on low income such as working/non-working spouses).
IR35 is aimed at the individual and not the Limited company/Umbrella company. It is policed through the existing self-assessment regime. As well as the tax the Inland Revenue determines has been avoided, penalties will also be applied which can be up to 100% of the tax avoided.
IR35 Employment status (test)
Outlined below is a guide to the general test that the Inland Revenue perform to help decide status under IR35. You should consider each of the criteria separately and then at the end try to conclude what the cumulative effect is in assessing whether or not the contract is either akin to employed or self-employed status
You should consider each point individually, however, no particular point should be looked at in isolation when forming your opinion of any contract, as the Inland Revenue are not know
known to rule on an individual area, only on the overall position.
Control:- Does the end client dictate duties and work to be performed each day? If yes this is a strong indication of being “employed”. If your contract states that you control and dictate what you do on a daily basis, and how the work is to be completed, this is a strong indication of being “self-employed”.
Pay:- If your contract clearly states that you will be paid on an hourly, daily, weekly or monthly basis, this is a strong indication of being “employed”. If you have an agreement to be paid in stages based on completion/part-completion of the project or task, this would look more like being “self-employed”
Financial Risk and Business Management:- If your business offers you the opportunity to make a profit in good times and the potential to suffer financially in bad times, this can be a strong indicator of self-employment. Having a fixed cost element to your contract, meaning you will suffer loss if you are unable to complete the services in agreed timescales, will strongly lean towards self-employment. If you are paid regardless of how well you do, and merely for turning up to work each day, you are probably going to be perceived as employed in the eyes of the Inland Revenue.
If you use the client’s equipment and don’t have the option to purchase/supply your own for the provision of the services, this can be deemed to be an indicator of employment. By having the option to buy and use your own equipment on site (or elsewhere), you potentially suffer a loss of value on this, therefore creating financial risk.
Substitution:- If you have the right to substitute in your contract, this is a strong indicator of self-employment. This is regardless of whether you have actually substituted or not. If you do not have the right to make a substitution and the name of the individual supplying the services is clearly stated in the contract, this can be seen as an indicator of employment.
Termination:- If you and the client can terminate your contract with a fixed notice period, this can be seen as suggesting employment. If termination is only due to breach, then this would suggest self-employment. In practise, this is usually difficult to negotiate away from as the majority of clients will require a notice period.
Duration:- If you work on one contract for a long time, this can be considered a career position and therefore a form of employment. If you are only working for the end client for a short time, then this may suggest self-employment.
Classification: - Are you classified as a skilled worker who provides services to different clients in a professional and business like fashion? If so, this would suggest that you have a status of self-employment
We all hold a certain status and often we'll hold different levels of status in different circumstances. The CEO of a large corporation may hold high status at work but could hold low status within the local church or ParkRun community. In virtually every group we exist within, there w
A key component in becoming an elite influencer is developing your ability to listen, and crucially, listen well. Listening is an essential skill, but to be able to listen you must have first encouraged the other person in your interaction to talk. The most common way to initiate a level of dial
By Applied Influence Group Prior to Barack Obama's decision in April 2016 to authorise the mobilisation of ground troops in Iraq and Syria, he had called the US' intervention in the region 'a dumb war', he had opposed previous troop surges during the Bush administration, promised to withdraw all
The JM Group (IT Recruitment) and sister company Longbridge Recruitment last week announced the opening of their new 5,500 square feet office in the City of London. The new space includes five meeting rooms named after parent company Staffing 360 Solutions' other global offices, a chill-out a
The biggest mobile show on earth, Mobile World Congress, is about to take place in the Mobile World Capital of Barcelona for the 13th year in a row. At this year's event, the prominent theme is "creating a better future with mobile technology," with mobile communication now reaching nearly 5 billion
In the second episode of In the Stress Lab, Cathy Harris and Renee van der Vloodt from Keychange Coaching sat down to discuss workplace stress and offer some very practical things to address this growing problem. · How do we define well-being and how does it
If I told you a recruitment consultant entered into a year-long programme to lead a monastic-life, led by the Archbishop of Canterbury, you would be forgiven for thinking it was penance for the much-documented sins of recruiters. It is, in fact, the story of Rebecca Green, on
The car has the potential to become the ultimate loyalty card. The car is essentially an extension of our everyday lives. Most people use their car every day, spending a considerable amount of time listening to music on the radio or making important phone calls on the go. As a result, drivers s
Future proofing your organisation When people think of innovation, they tend to think of a new product, like the iPhone, or the driverless car. Think a little harder, and a company might think of making a process more efficient, like Toyota did with car making, or changing a business model, l
31st January is the day workers are most likely to hand in their notice. If you are one of these people looking to move on then it's important to hand in your notice the right way. We Brits generally don't enjoy confrontation or awkwardness, so for most people, giving notice is not usually an enj
Tired of buzzwords, glitchy new handsets, smartwatches, talks about how AI will replace employees, virtual reality shopping replacing physical stores, and other technology trends that hardly impact you in the short term? Then this is the trend report for you. We believe that the winners of th
31st January is the day workers are most likely to hand in their notice. If you are one of these people looking to move on then it’s important to hand in your notice the right way. We Brits generally don’t enjoy confrontation or awkwardness, so for most people, giving notice is no
The biggest mobile show on earth, Mobile World Congress, is about to take place in the Mobile World Capital of Barcelona for the 13th year in a row. At this year’s event, the prominent theme is “creating a better future with mobile technology,” with mobile communication now reaching nearly 5 b
Future proofing your organisation When people think of innovation, they tend to think of a new product, like the iPhone, or the driverless car. Think a little harder, and a company might think of making a process more efficient, like Toyota did with car making, or changing a business model, like
By Applied Influence Group Prior to Barack Obama’s decision in April 2016 to authorise the mobilisation of ground troops in Iraq and Syria, he had called the US’ intervention in the region ‘a dumb war’, he had opposed previous troop surges during the Bush administration, promised to w
If I told you a recruitment consultant entered into a year-long programme to lead a monastic-life, led by the Archbishop of Canterbury, you would be forgiven for thinking it was penance for the much-documented sins of recruiters. It is, in fact, the story of Rebecca Green, one of the JM Group